cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ml/post/52667780
I’ve started investing in ETFs (S&P 500) but wonder if it would be better to buy a property instead and put it to rent.
I’m in my early 40s and I plan to regularly invest in this and similar worldwide ETFs in the next 25 years, as complement to my public pension.
A coworker told me he saved money to buy a house and put it to rent. He can always move in if he wants and it gives him a stable source of income per month. I don’t know how much.
I don’t know if investing in ETFs in wiser here: on one hand I want a quiet life and now I simply work and the money gets invested automatically once per month. I’ve never been a landlord and I wonder if the learning curve would be too steep. Furthermore, I don’t believe I want to be a landlord. Ain’t it too stressful?
A property let’s you more easily use leverage , which can be good and bad. Property to rent brings all sorts of tenant risks and unforseen expenses though. Houses run down and need maintenance etx. Not my thing, and I eschewed that.
IMO etfs and keep topping up each month and be frugal. SCHD, VOO add an international ETF etal and reinvest. Closer to retirement, (be it earlier or not) transition some/most of the portfolio to more income focused e.g. GPIQ, GPIX, TDAQ, TSYX etal.
This was a similar to the strategy i employed when i was 20, had me retired at 40 and am now 60 and still compounding.
Furthermore, I don’t believe I want to be a landlord. Ain’t it too stressful?
If an investment would keep you awake at night, it’s the wrong investment for you. From the Bogleheads investment philosophy (mostly USA centric, but easily tweaked for non-USA):
Aim to select an asset allocation that lets you sleep at night, and avoid the destructive urge to sell out in a panic the next time the market plummets, then having to worry over when is the time to get back in. This leads to selling low and buying high, the exact opposite of prudent investing.
As you said, your time horizon is at least 25 years. Would you want to be a landlord (even one that just outsources everything to a property management company) for nearly three decades?
I will offer two anecdotes from colleagues of mine that pursued rental property. The first colleague came from a family of real estate agents, and basically every branch of his extended family already had rental properties. He now has six rental properties and benefitted from the extensive “knowledge capital” within his family on how to do rentals properly. He’s also good with DIY and carefully selected long-term tenants that reliably pay rent, so he doesn’t have to raise rent often, which keeps turnover low. It was clear he would be fine as a landlord, as a part of his diversified portfolio.
My second colleague became a landlord because he got married and moved to a different area to start a family, meaning his original home could be rented out. He wasn’t too far though, so he took care of the property maintenance himself. As it happened, when he had twins, there wasn’t much time left to deal with the rental, and in the end it was easier to just sell it and focus on his family. He made positive money from the sale, but the nature of holding just a single rental property means it could equally have been a loss if market conditions were different. I think he made the right move to simplify his portfolio, because although his retirement time horizon is decades out, he only has so many years to be a doting father. Life changes should ideally not cause one’s portfolio to be overhauled.
Just do the etfs unless you already make your own hours and are good at finding trades people that don’t suck.
With a 25-year horizon and a preference for a quiet life, ETFs fit your situation better: they stay liquid, diversified and automatic, while a rental adds tenant, maintenance and vacancy work. I would only choose the property if the net rent after all costs clearly beat the ETF return and I was happy being a landlord.
Rental property is a very different job from an ETF, not just a different investment. Before comparing returns, do the honest math on a rental: subtract vacancy (a month or two empty every few years), maintenance and repairs (a common rule is 1% of the property value per year), property tax, insurance, and any management fees. Then compare what’s left to the return you’d get on the same money in a broad index fund. Many people find the net yield is a lot lower than the headline rent.
Also consider concentration: a rental puts a big chunk of your wealth in one building in one town, usually with a loan, while a world ETF is spread over thousands of companies and costs you zero hours.
You already said you don’t think you’d enjoy being a landlord, and that matters. Since your plan is automatic monthly investing for 25 years, it’s perfectly reasonable to keep doing that and revisit property only if you find a place you’d want to live in anyway.


