Somebody (presumably from the USA) complained about “Open Street Maps just not being as updated as Google.”
That got me thinking. I’m from Europe.
First of all I haven’t had a Google account or regularly used any of their products for over a decade. So I need to ask.
And by Openstreetmap (OSM) I mean the maps themselves that are used by many apps, routing services, and even secondary map providers.
OSM is community-driven. It requires people to actively participate, or at least deliberately install apps that do that I guess, to create maps and keep them up-to-date.
Google Maps is an app. Where do the maps come from? The data they get automatically (from their users; one might claim it’s community driven too, lol) and those cars with those weird cameras on top and probably something else. Maybe they even take from OSM.
OSM probably won’t ever be able to “see” traffic jams, but apart from that it works very well, gives me a satisfying mapping and navigation experience by car, bike or foot.
And many big professional/official sites rely on OSM.
So, is that not the case in other places in the world, e.g. the USA? How often do you see these Google cars? I haven’t seen one in ages. Let’s say once a year.
I hope you get the main drive of my question. It’s about how crtain “alternatives” to Big tech work, and are perceived, in different places around the world, although the Europe-USA comparison is bugging me the most.
Yes I was talking about you and some of the replies you got, but didn’t want to name you.
From the replies I’m getting across 3 posts I’d say it’s somewhat true that where I live OSM has it easier and Google has it harder, compared to the USA.
Which results in OSM being at least comparable if not even better.
BTW I don’t really buy OSM being better rural than urban because here ALL public transport apps (i.e. urban) use OSM. Off-road stuff though, OSM might be generally better there.
I’ve never heard the rural vs urban argument explicitly, but I guess I made the implicit assumption based on how many of the OSM apps seem to advertise being friendly to outdoor activities. Their offline capability probably helps that image too.
It’s been made more than once, also in the 3 posts I made about this.
Interesting, I never thought of it before.