What you think neurosurgeon should be worse compensated so that they’ll continue being neurosurgeon?? They won’t even become neurosurgeon in the first place if you don’t offer to pay them well!
You have your concept of incentives completely backwards - you’re looking at methods of fear to motivate people to take part in a completely voluntary aspect of society. People can leave the country, not work at all, or get different jobs. You need to pay neurosurgeon well.
I do not see neurosurgeon leaving en-masse currently and they are the best paid in the medical profession right now. They instead reach tenureship quickly and then focus on training more neurosurgeon, which is less stressful for them and just as well paid, or almost as well paid.
And because of the existing high pay incentive, LOADS of people are training under them to become surgeons. Ergo the system works.
You are trying to solve problems where no problem exists because too much communist theory has you thinking that everything has to be symmetrical - but society is not symmetrical
Rant: Scientists aren’t fundamentally better. They just have learned how to do science.
Yes they are fundamentally better at what they do - science - which is why they are paid more for what they do - science - because other people, generally speaking, cannot do it. I also do not see doctors as scientists strictly speaking, they’re something even more valuable.
is being made hard due to societal decisions such as high study costs etc. but that doesn’t make them superior
This is not the reason jobs like doctoring and engineering are paid better and you probably know that, deek down. Look at free lectures on the subject matter if you need to prove it to yourself. It’s essentially supply and demand, which is a fundamental law of the universe.
A artisan is also a highly skilled trade and is performed by intelligent people who also took risk in their career.
My issue is with people commiserating the working man for they did not manage to do neurosurgery. People not respecting but looking down upon the plebs.
What you think neurosurgeon should be worse compensated so that they’ll continue being neurosurgeon?? They won’t even become neurosurgeon in the first place if you don’t offer to pay them well!
You have your concept of incentives completely backwards - you’re looking at methods of fear to motivate people to take part in a completely voluntary aspect of society. People can leave the country, not work at all, or get different jobs. You need to pay neurosurgeon well.
I do not see neurosurgeon leaving en-masse currently and they are the best paid in the medical profession right now. They instead reach tenureship quickly and then focus on training more neurosurgeon, which is less stressful for them and just as well paid, or almost as well paid.
And because of the existing high pay incentive, LOADS of people are training under them to become surgeons. Ergo the system works.
You are trying to solve problems where no problem exists because too much communist theory has you thinking that everything has to be symmetrical - but society is not symmetrical
Yes they are fundamentally better at what they do - science - which is why they are paid more for what they do - science - because other people, generally speaking, cannot do it. I also do not see doctors as scientists strictly speaking, they’re something even more valuable.
This is not the reason jobs like doctoring and engineering are paid better and you probably know that, deek down. Look at free lectures on the subject matter if you need to prove it to yourself. It’s essentially supply and demand, which is a fundamental law of the universe.
A artisan is also a highly skilled trade and is performed by intelligent people who also took risk in their career.
My issue is with people commiserating the working man for they did not manage to do neurosurgery. People not respecting but looking down upon the plebs.