Mastodon

Have you ever considered that the Prime Directive is not only not ethical, but also illogical, and perhaps morally indefensible?

  • 3.41K Posts
  • 3.29K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023

help-circle




  • This has alwasy been a favourite of mine - high-concept nonsense at its finest.

    The core of a society spending their entire lives in their cars is incredibly on-the-nose, and I love it. RTD does what he does best, creating a world of memorable characters who each seem like they have full lives and personalities, with very little screen time. They really sell the absolutely absurd concept.

    I don’t think I’ve heard “The Old Rugged Cross” outside of this episode - Gospel isn’t exactly my thing - but it’s used well here, and I’m surprised to learn that it’s an American song, and not something with British roots.

    The “mood dealers” are an interesting idea, but somewhat underbaked. It seems like something they could have done more with, but here they’re mainly a plot device to explain what happened to the overcity.

    The idea of the Doctor bringing Martha back to New New New New New New New New New New New New New New New York is pretty solid, though I wish Martha didn’t complain about it the way that she does. The unrequited crush angle continues to underwhelm, even though it’s handled better in this episode than elsewhere. It’s helped along by the fact that we can see the Doctor fighting with himself, slowly opening himself up to her against his own better judgement.

    It’s also nice to see the Face of Boe one last time - I’ve always felt that the character is diminished by the Captain Jack connection, and treat him as a separate character.

    Oh, and Sally Calypso deserves her own spinoff based on her name alone.




























  • I agree - the new government in Quebec has an obvious stake in reopening the Constitution, and Ford’s the kind of guy who would jump on it. They meet the 50% of the population stipulation all by themselves, and between them and Alberta, they have 3 out of the 7 provinces required. It’s not implausible that they could find four more.

    BUT, the current version of Ford might not be too excited to be seen climbing into bed with separatists.




  • I was prepared to come in with a half-assed gag about how this is one of the episodes of all time…but I disliked it even more than I remembered.

    It’s not silly enough to be a romp, and it’s not scary enough to be a horror (despite seeming like a Halloween episode, this one apparently aired in April). It doesn’t really engage with the time period or Shakespeare himself in a meaningful way. It’s just blandly there, for the most part.

    It’s not very kind to Martha. The Doctor dismisses her concerns about being a Black woman in Elizabethan London. She doesn’t get to do any meaningful doctoring, which would have given her some agency in the story. They didn’t even make her a theatre nerd - she seems to have about as much familiarity with Shakespeare as the average person. But hey, she got to feel sad about the Doctor being hung up on Rose. Character development.

    Shakespeare himself doesn’t get much, either - I actually think his initial “rock star” introduction is pretty fun, but he’s little more than a series of gags after that. Much is made about his genius, and his grief over losing Hamnet, but neither comes through in the writing or performance.

    Sprinkle in too many references to Rowling that have aged like milk, and we’ve got an episode that I have no desire to revisit again any time soon.