befwuf [comrade/them]

  • 3 Posts
  • 17 Comments
Joined 2 months ago
cake
Cake day: October 7th, 2026

help-circle

  • The Nazi party grew from killing labor organizers and communists, and was installed against the will of the people.

    This sounds more like a coup from the Nazis than from the bourgeoisie. How did they push them into power?

    The capitalist state army is not a mindless drone that sides directly with whoever is in charge of the state. It sides with capital. Allende was coup’ed by the Chilean military.

    I need to learn more about Allende history, but why is that? What makes the military defend capital, not the government?

    you do not see that the state is reliant upon and reinforced by the mode of production

    No I don’t. I don’t see what would concretely prevent the state from turning against the bourgeoisie.


  • Because capitalists control the commanding heights of the economy, they control the state, and can rip away the illusion of bourgeois democracy at any time they wish, essentially implementing fascism.

    How would it materialize concretely in a western social democracy country?

    The capitalist state is a state for capitalism, it isn’t a neutral state that can be swapped piece by piece.

    Yes, as I said, I’m not talking about reformism, but the party completely replacing the state by the dictatorship of the proletariat, just like a revolution, but from the inside.

    A Marxist party cannot expropriate the bourgeoisie through decree, it must come through force

    Why couldn’t they do both? Pass the law, and seize the means of production using the state army and the armed workers.







  • Thank you for your great answer again.

    In my experience, many people simply want the government to improve their living conditions—whether through higher wages or lower prices. In other words, they seek to improve capitalism rather than replace the economic system entirely with something better. You are right: most Western proletarians do not actively challenge their state’s imperialist stance. But even so, why don’t they want to nationalize their largest corporations, instead of just raising their tax for example?






  • sometimes everyone doesn’t always get their own personal bathroom or whatever. You collectively make decisions on who gets what.

    Absolutely, but in this case, the total number of bathrooms and the number of people living in the household are usually known, and the decision only needs to be made once. This becomes much trickier when the total amount of resource is unknown, and the needs for the resource evolves unpredictably over time. Even for a single person, there is no way to compute the optimal amount of a limited resource that can be consumed now for comfort after satisfying basic needs if the same resource might be required to meet future unpredictable needs. I think the corresponding scientific model would be the “online resource allocation problem”.


  • communism will take hundreds and hundreds of years to successfully develop

    This depresses me. We need communism now.

    I agree with you. We can’t get it perfect ahead of time, it will most likely be an iterative process of improvement. But if we suddenly dismantle the current system now, my fear is that without broad consensus, however vague, society will divide. People might have concerns, uncertainties, or misunderstandings about the new system that we could have addressed earlier, which could prevent them from cooperating and leave us vulnerable to a counter-offensive or takeovers. This is even more of a major problem if the first country to do so is under significant pressure from other governments.




  • No, I have no doubt that people will be able to adequately allocate resources to meet their needs without overproduction or prices.

    I just wonder how we will decide the allocation trade-off between strict requirements, such as desks, notebooks, pens, vs quality of life, not strictly necessary goods, such as better computers, video projectors, air conditioning etc. Basically, how will we choose the level of comfort we allow ourselves when it depends on limited resources and could reduce the ability to meet our basic needs in the future?


  • Thank you sincerely for your kind understanding, and helping me seeing beyond my bias.

    I completely agree with you. I have no doubt that communities will be able to allocate resources to meet their needs. My question was more about how to decide the allocation trade-off between strict requirements, such as housing, food, health care, etc., and comfort or convenience goods, such as premium food, premium bedding, dishwasher, high-end tech devices, beauty products, etc. We could meet all our basic needs with minimal resources, but how will we choose the level of comfort we allow ourselves when it depends on limited resources and could reduce the ability to meet our basic needs in the future?