randomquery [none/use name,any]

  • 1 Post
  • 9 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 3rd, 2022

help-circle


  • But where did the mother erred them ? i can follow this hole allegory “the father (west) germany” , the Mother “Socialism /east germany” i think thats brilliant , but it makes it even more “pro GDR” then. the Father clearly constitutes the central issue of the family. Hes the Antagonist if there is one.

    I would agree with this view if it was not for the mother’s confession and what came after (and I was actually finding the movie much more positive of the GDR up to that point), but the confession really turns it around. The confession of the mother is done in such a way that redeems the father of almost any potential wrongdoing:

    • He doesn’t want to go to the west because he is greedy and wants to live the petit bourgeois fantasy of a professional (which is how many professionals were actually enticed to leave the GDR), but because he didn’t want to join the party and thus the party was making his life difficult (he chose capitalism not because of greed but because he wanted to be free from the party oppression)
    • He wrote letters to his children expressing his love to them which the mother hid
    • When his son visits him, he is very receptive of him, even skips his moment of appreciation at the party where he gives a very brief speech and immediately goes to his long lost child
    • He confesses to his son that he waited to hear from them for 3 years (which he says were the most difficult years he had to live and was waiting every day to hear from them - maybe I am stretching it here, but it takes 3 years between the postdam conference that splits germany into zones and the agreement between US, France, and Britain to unite their zones and found the west german republic, summer 1945 to spring 1948, which leads to the soviet decision of the creation of the GDR). His starting of a new family is the development of the west german republic that “leaves behind” the children in the east.
    • He immediately agrees to meet her, and is very kind with her as she is about to die

    On the other had the mother through her confession makes herself almost completely irredeemable:

    • She hides the letters, and lies to her children about their father (she says he abandons them for greed)
    • She doesn’t decide to stay in the east out of a moral conviction, out of a belief that the socialist system is better, she decides to stay out of fear

    I think this second point is also very interesting. The only moment that offers us a means to empathize with the mother is how she rationalizes her fear that led her to stay in the east, when she says that she was worried the state would separate her from her children (this seems to be the instance where the metaphor breaks, and she is no longer a metaphor for GDR, but then at this moment the GDR is again presented negatively). Even more so, this confession that she stayed because of fear and not out of any moral conviction, falsifies the rest of her life after her husband left (and in the metaphor falsifies the “real” socialist character of the GDR). All these letters she was sending about criticism and improvement, the award she received, all her involvement in the party, the meetings and so on, they are not real, they do not stem out of any conviction she held about the socialist project, they are in some sense as false when they really happen in her life as the theatre her son plans to not stress her. This theme fits also in the usual western “left” criticism of the soviet and GDR project, that it pretended to be socialist, with the meetings, and workers democracy but it was all fake, theatre, and people were living in fear in these societies.

    There are of course some events one can see as criticism of the west/father. For example, in the end the father does live the petit bourgeois fantasy, with a big house, the party, the stereotypical family, being loved and respected by his friends. One could also ask why as soon as the wall fell, he didn’t try to go and find them immediately, why he waited. But I felt that the movie didn’t try to highlight and push these points.

    Anyway, this is my take, I am probably overthinking it, but it was a very interesting experience re-watching this movie after many years while my views have also changed, so thanks for sharing!







  • Looking at it this way, the major losers of the twentieth century were those who believed too sincerely in the existence of a liberal international order, those who trusted too much in democracy, or too much in what the United States said it supported, rather than what it really supported—what the rich countries said, rather than what they did. That group was annihilated.