- cross-posted to:
- weibsvolk@feddit.org
You never really can predict what the players will do. I once started a game where the party woke up hung over in a tavern with very little memory of what had transpired the previous night. Several players (the two “alphas” at the table) were so convinced that their characters could not get black out drunk and that some conspiracy must be afoot they spent the rest of the year long game tracking down a gnomish bard I threw in for flavor when describing the bits and pieces they did remember.
I once derailed a whole session by… asking a squirrel where the big bad boss was.
I mean, we knew he was hiding in the forest! I had both the option to talk to animals and charm them! What could you expect!
Suffice to say, the session finished 5 minutes later because the DM hadn’t planned the big encounter yet, but had a host of cool traps ready for us if we had followed the marked path
If was DMing that game, that squirrel would have taken you to the meanest cat in the woods, owned by a witch and she would’ve had more quests for you. Unless you killed the cat…
Pls name the cat Greebo
It didn’t squirrel out of the question?
As a (very weak) defense, usually adventuring is expected to be quite male dominated… exclusion of women is kind of embedded in the plot (cfr Éowyn and how upset she was about it, admission of the author that women were sidelined)
And that’s why representation matters: because it snowballs and creates more presence.
And that’s why AI sucks, because it drinks up all our biases and spouts them back, often even worse. But because they confirm our world view they are hard to spot.
As a (very weak) defense, usually adventuring is expected to be quite male dominated…
Oh totally. I even noticed it with myself. I am currently reading “The dwarves” by Markus Heitz and the adventure group ends up with one female character. I didn’t even bat an eye and it does not feel weird at all. Because as you say, it is (sadly) the default that it is male dominated. I think if it was genderflipped, I would have noticed that something is different. I would be happy about it for sure, but it is noticeable.
If there’s nothing interesting for the women to do when the men away, then surely the men were single losers without any responsibilities in their lives…
Like during WW2 when women entered industry en-masse because the men were away fighting
Take viking society. Men during the summer went sailing and exploring and maybe plundering and often trading and meeting other vikings. Women and children stayed home to take care of the herds and the fields. Both are work, only one is glamorous.
WWII women were elated to be finally in the same role as men, while war, the male domain, went from noble and rewarding to a mass death camp.
WWII women made great spies due to Nazi prejudices.
Viking women could own property, and there were women-led rebellions. Things to do, so the vikings pass this test
I do this quite a lot while writing plays. There’s often a character that’s gender-locked (a catholic priest would have to be male) and certain groups of characters where I want to keep the overall gender polarity, but a lot of them could be either, so I try flipping the genders in my head from time to time. Sometimes it leads to improvements.
Of course, a lot of this comes down to which actors are available - it’s not a requirement, but in many cases it’s better to keep the character-actor gender aligned (or, occasionally, intentionally misaligned).
So while I do assign genders to the characters from the start, I always keep an open mind and see who can be gender-swapped.
That’s a great practice. I’d also suggest, if a large portion of characters are gender locked as the same gender (for example historical soldiers or a convent), to consider intentionally adding 1 or 2 characters of other genders just to broaden the scope of the story. This probably won’t always be possible but if done it will certainly help keep the piece from feeling flat and unrealistic. Which is how most all male cast stories feel to me.
Damn. Had a reply all ready, but I just realised this is /c/WomensStuff. I saw the post in /all and didn’t realise I was intruding.
I’d be interested to hear what your planned reply was.
Just that the way I work each character has a reason for existing, plus I’m targetting roughly the number of actors available (there’s some leeway, multiple smaller roles can be done by a single person).
Plus much like most theatre groups, we usually have more girls, so I try to accomodate that, aiming at whatever gender balance exists. Still, it’s a nice exercise to flip various characters beack and forth, see what ends up working better.
Ah, that makes sense. I only write fiction as a hobby so there’s no limiting factors for me in terms of main characters. I also write with a focus on heavy world building so including a large cross section of society is important for me.




