Credits: https://old.reddit.com/r/BuyFromEU/comments/1j9g5h8/i_left_dropbox_as_a_heavy_user_of_15_years/
I had everything in my Dropbox: all my legal documents, my work-related files, my photos from the last 20 years, and things people sent me that I want to look at again when I’m 80… I literally had my life stored in it (and of course locally on two machines and a extra backup disk). I also accessed it almost daily via my phone and uploaded files from my phone.
So, I tested several services in the range of ~100 Euros a year with at least 1,5 Terabytes:
Jottacloud:
- Good Desktop Client (Win & Mac)
- Very good iOS App
- Good service
- Pricey (144 Euros for unlimited storage)
- Downside for me: it doesn’t automatically convert photo uploads from my phone to JPG and doesn’t store them in a folder I choose – plus, the price is high.
Filen:
- Good Desktop Client (Win & Mac)
- Rough iOS App
- Good service
- Okay price (108 Euros for 2TB)
- Downside for me: the rough iOS App didn’t have a document upload with a scan function.
Nextcloud:
- Good Desktop Client (Win & Mac)
- Good iOS App
- No dedicated service; it’s Open Source, so some tinkering is required since you manage the hosting yourself.
- Weird price range (Hetzner, the cheapest host by far, offers either 60 Euros for 1TB or 200 Euros for 5TB, nothing in between).
- Downside for me: the price range.
kDrive:
- Good Desktop Client (Win & Mac)
- Very good iOS App
- Amazing service, document editing included, etc.
- Amazing price (60 Euros per year for 3TB)
- Downside for me: none.
So, I chose kDrive, even though I’d love to use Nextcloud because it’s Open Source and you can choose your own host. If I needed less than 1TB, I’d definitely choose Nextcloud.
And it should be said that all the services I tested offer free options with a few Gigabytes, if that’s all you need.
Does Kdrive have a family plan?
If you have at least one system which is always on and online somewhere, you can synchronise files within your own managed ring with syncthing. It does require having enough space on each device for the synced files, but it has its uses. It can also sync specific folders with specific devices, so you could choose to not synchronise all of that ~1.5TB with mobile devices. As an example of how I use it; I sync my mobile’s photos folder with my NAS for sorting into the larger Pictures collection once I get to it, then just access that NAS when needed. A secure DynDNS service could give access to that NAS from other locations where required. Best of all; Syncthing is FREE.
Yes, that’s a great option too. Maybe you should make a post about Syncthing, this approach probably deserves some visibility
Hetzner Storage Share (Nextcloud) is super cheap, managed and runs very well for me.
I wanted to ask you, does it give access to a whole Nextcloud instance, including apps like Talk (https://nextcloud.com/talk/)? Or is it only file storage?
Yes its a full NC instance, we use the same hosting for our companies NC and Talk is working fine.
It should be a complete Nextcloud installation with all preinstalled apps included. Otherwise they would not be allowed to advertise it as a “Nextcloud” installation and would be obliged to remove all branding.
I would like to put a link to the official Nextcloud guidline on that topic but I can’t find itPerfect, great!
I’m having a look now, it says 5.19€ per month max and 0.0083€ per hour, with a page saying
How precisely does Hetzner calculate the hourly billing?
The beginning of the hourly billing starts as soon as the product becomes available to you. We always round up when calculating the hourly use. If you only use the product for a few minutes, we will charge you a full hour. If you use the product for close to a month, and the montly price is cheaper, we will always charge you the cheaper monthly price rather than a higher hourly price.
https://docs.hetzner.com/general/others/new-billing-model
So in the case of a Nextcloud service, Hetzner would only bill the hours during which I sync files and makes calls for instance? Or would there be a base fee for storage (after all, the files stay on their servers all the time)
I would assume this is for services using computing power rather than storage. The Nextcloud storage probably costs what you say it costs.
For me it’s really just a matter of which Nextcloud provider I subscribe to, as open source and guaranteed good Linux support is pretty high on my list of demands.
For reference, Dropbox prices are:
€120/yr: 2TB
€200/yr: 3TB
€60/yr: One additional terrabyte of storageI guess the pricing is relative depending on needs - if you need to host a bunch of stuff, Jottacloud suddenly seems very reasonable. If a few gigabytes for your holiday pictures is enough, less so.
Makes sense, thanks.
Yes, I was confused by the hourly price, not sure why they would add it, seems confusing.
Actually I just realized they probably just added add as 5€ divided by the number of hours per month as an indication
Yep, as you said
Since the new hetzner pricing the site is more confusing but the big price is the one that matters most of the time lol
I think they offer a bunch of more complex services to business consumers, which makes their website a bit confusing to tiny people like us. I think it’s probably wise to focus only on the information on this page.
That’s where I got the hourly price from:
kSuite Plus with the 1Tb offer and a free @ik.me mail. (in my language it says @me.me which I find funny)
Very happy with how kSuite integrates. Their import tool is also great. made me drop dropbox, onedrive, google drive
I checked out nextcloud and koofr when switching from Google drive and settled on koofr. In terms of the criteria you outlined above:
- Decent desktop client + network drive which appears like a USB key in your file system, super usable
- Very good android app
- No document editing but you can open everything from the network drive using the editing software on your device and it syncs to the cloud
- Nice price (45 euro for 200GB, which is all I need)
- Downside: no integrated document suite for editing in the browser but the workaround with the network drive is very straightforward (one click to enable in the desktop client)
I don’t need a massive amount of cloud storage, in the terabytes, say, so I’ve found koofr ideal for my purposes. Another bonus for me is it’s a Slovene company so must be GDPR compliant.
Thank you for sharing!
No worries, thanks for your original post 👌
Have a look at Tresorit
IONOS has a really good deal on Nextcloud.
Maybe you want to take a look into PCloud - 100€ per year for 2TB of storage, no online office, but afaik local encryption possible before upload.
It also gives the possibility for “lifetime” plans - pay once, use forever.
I recently (~3 weeks ago) switched to pCloud (lifetime plan) coming from Dropbox and thus far I’m extremely happy with switching! European and one subscription less to worry about, win-win!
