To hasan’s editor a Palestinian refugee that was arrested in the west bank for protesting against the settler state is a “worthless bot created by zios to divide and conquer”

Send all streamers and fans into a pit barbara-pit

Salin’s responce

I don’t care about them being in my mentions

All I care about is that leftists stop endorsing/promoting/supporting Zionists I really don’t give a fuck about anything else

I’ll give you an example, you met with Bernie at least two times after he exposed himself to be a Jewish Supremacist and went against a ceasefire in the worst portion of the genocide - you never ever even dreamed about treating him like you treat anyone who criticize you from the left

Bernie is a Jewish supremacist and is complicit directly in genocide and you fully support him

You had ample chances to confront him, AOC, Mamdani etc on their Zionism, support for genocide, betrayal of solidarity with Palestine - you never do.

The genocide happened exactly because of 80+ years of this type of acceptance of Jewish supremacy in the US and Europe

https://x.com/nukedwest/status/2057665902007455912

  • Carl [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    54
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    6 个月前

    i believe two things

    1. Hasan is genuinely anti zionist

    2. Hasan is not sufficiently hostile to zionists, especially soft zionists like bernie, and that his actions in this realm are at least partially dictated by his material conditions being tied to his association with the Democratic party, and that this is one of the mechanisms by which people with radical views become coopted by establishment organizations, and if Hasan does not realize and accept that he is in this pipeline and do something to get out of it that will by definition put his access and livelihood at risk then in five years (or sooner!) he’s going to find himself interviewing Contrapoints and agreeing with her about how annoying radicals are

    c) Hasan’s collaborators are in the same pipeline and must make the same realization and break with their meal ticket if he doesn’t in order to get off of the track they’re on

      • RomCom1989@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        25
        ·
        6 个月前

        Because it’s not about him as a figure being infallible,far from it

        It is a combination of the radicalization he helped incite in many who used him as a starting off point for their own journey left and the fact that he did things such as go to Cuba with the Nuestra America flotilla and have Palestinian voices on the program,as well as left figures with reasonable credentials such as Melanchon and Varoufakis

        And I just simply don’t buy the narrative that he’s a Vaush or a Contrapoints type or that he’s a grifter or a Fed or whatever

        One,you can do all of those things for way less effort and way less backlash,so I don’t get the argument that he’s grifting off of what is a very small audience that would be receptive to said grift when there are much better cash cows to milk

        And two, if he were any of those things, why would such figures agree to be on the same broadcast as he is and have their beliefs promoted? Are they that clueless or desperate that they can’t sniff out something being off?

        I think people like to slide into the comfortable narrative that he’s insincere because it’s easier to square that circle than admit that people have malleable morals and will bend and twist them in order to get what they think is a beneficial outcome. Basically,I think he’s sincere about what he says,and that the true disagreement here is about the method rather than the moral character of the person.

        You are perfectly well within your rights to lambast him for collaborating with liberal Zionists and attempting to do entryism into the Dems in the hopes that they do something drastic and implode, basically pushing back the formation of a socialist pole in American politics to a fuzzy and uncertain day when shit is hitting the fan rapidly right now and people getting stuck on a side quest of making the democrat party implode wastes time and progress that could have been made,but I do understand his logic for doing what he does,even if I disagree with it.

      • free_casc [comrade/them]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        13
        ·
        edit-2
        6 个月前

        Edit: RomCom said it better

        He has consistently represented anti-zionist and anti-imperialism, even when it was costly to him. He has serves a role in moving those views toward the political mainstream, of which he is on the cusp. He should be offered grace proportional to these actions. I do think his effect on the US left, which has badly needed an injection of anti-zionism and anti-imperialism, is measurable.

        As a consequence he has been the target of a massive amount of personal and institutional harassment. As he communicates to his audience, it has been tough for him to be nearly driven away from his media career by the agents of Zionism (US institutions, Israeli institutions, dipshit online dramalords), yet he understands that this is incomparable to the vicitms of of genocide and other imperial violence that he intends to stand up for.

        He ought to be offered grace in proportion to these activities.

        He has also been soft on certain [liberal] Zionists he has interacted with. He is getting involved with electoral politics, which can send a mixed and undisciplined message that could lead to a dead end ( I don’t personally strongly agree with this, but it is a concern). His intent is that the moment is now to use electoral politics to carve out a land for the anti-zionist/anti-imperial perspective, in the same way that the Bernie campaigns carved out a lane for ““socialism”” (domestic social democratic policies) in the US polticial sphere. At the same time, it is obviously concerning that the Democratic machine could subsume the anti-imperial energy in the way it has with the social democratic energy (they can’t even do “kind imperialism” properly). I would say we dont know how it will paly out because it hasn’t happened yet.

        Nonetheless, he ought to be offered criticism in proportion to these activities.

  • FlakesBongler [they/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    38
    ·
    6 个月前

    It’s absolutely telling that whenever you say, “Hey, we really shouldn’t be aiding and abetting genocide” you get some mealy-mouthed pishers going “What is it with you and these purity tests?”

    I dunno, maybe it’s because I have a soul and don’t think that people have to die because a bunch of end-times freaks think Israel needs to exist so God will start the Rapture

  • Rojo27 [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    22
    ·
    6 个月前

    There’s no such thing as a perfect antizionist because there’s no such thing as a partial or flawed antizionist. Its fucked up that now these radlibs want to play the “purity test” card when it comes to antizionism.