I currently work at an “AI First” 🤢 fintech company, and we’re mandated to program agentically. I was fortunate enough to start working before the AI hype, but the environment right now is daunting.
There’s too much unmaintainable code slop and throw away scripts committed that I can’t keep track anymore. Each PR has so much diffs that it feels like someone had diarrhea and shat all over.
I try to manually review the code, but it feels like best effort at most. Like I may only understand 70% of the thing that I’m reviewing. What ends up happening usually is that I just ask the model and verify the output(which is horrifying I know)
I spend the whole day arguing with AI, reviewing, and pushing back against its output that sometimes I wonder if I am the one driving AI or is it driving me.
–
Recently, I noticed that I’ve becoming more reliant on the model and that my skills have been atrophying. What would’ve taken me an afternoon if I program it by hand, would take me a week now if I do it now. I also find my head hurting and myself glossing over the code in code reviews and prompting claude to do even the basic of commands.
I get that there’s more to programming in software engineering (collaboration, dealing with people, etc etc), but I don’t feel like I am in control of the systems I am building anymore with the engineering aspect being replaced with babysitting and self lobotomy.
–
Off work hours, I try to brush up by reading on system design and architecture books, typing by hand if I’m learning a new technology or stack, but I feel like it’s not enough to prevent from skill atrophy.
How are y’all coping and how do you recover from this? I am afraid on what skills that I’ll be able to bring at my next place of employment if I resign and that I’m becoming a jack of all trades master of none type of thing - having only shallow understanding.
I made a horizontal career move and accepted as a trade-off that at this time I won’t write code.
Old company: mildly toxic environment, out of touch CEO, poor leadership. Increasing AI push and wild gaps between different people’s competence. Constant arguing. The dreaded 5k loc generated PRs started appearing. My role: ~5% web programming tasks (that I actually signed up for originally) rest was design, review, and people-related work. I was not a manager. Hated it.
The project: 1 year of goal-oriented homelabbing, from a 50€ raspberry pi to hybrid cloud, gitops, kubernetes, and all the good bleeding edge stuff you need to run your own cloud. Did this completely without AI, built the resume, applied to a few places. Happens that one of the companies was looking for the exact stack I built my homelab around.
New company: Platform team, 90% hands on, competent manager, capped AI budgets, people treat each other respectfully. I quite like it. When I do coding it’s simple enough that it stays manageable even though I ask some bot to write it 90% of the time. It gets the job done, I wasn’t hired to write code anyway.
It’s probably a patch, but I’m hoping to run the wave long enough by this move. For the first time in a couple years I feel clarity. I trust that I’ll be able to pick up programming by hand if needed. Most people are in the same boat anyway, so the expectation won’t be there to perform on a similar level instantly. I trust that my ability to learn new things keeps being valuable.
On my free time I don’t currently write code, non-technical hobbies and maintaining the homelab I conjured eat it up. I don’t mind too much. I have enough interesting stuff to do. I think most of all it’s important that I get to create something. If I’m not exactly paid to do that it’s not the end of the world. Much worse situations exist, I’m still paid similar €€ than in my software position.
Nice story and good on you that your new company respects you. Hard to find a good place these days.
On my free time I don’t currently write code, non-technical hobbies and maintaining the homelab I conjured eat it up.
I should get more non-technical hobbies, especially physical ones… But I’ll be literally sat at my wfh desk typing for work, looking forward to after 17h when I can switch the kvm to writing code for pleasure lol. I do really like programming though. Somehow still not sick of it after all these years.
Where I work we can still push back to big PRs. Our guideline is unchanged that it shouldn’t be more than 700 lines of change. The less the better. With agents it’s even simpler to deny a big PR. A manually written big PR would have meant lots of manual effort in reworking it. With agents I basically just demand the author to tell their agent to split their fucking PR up.
How do you push back if that PR comes from your boss or a more tenured eng
I am a Staff Engineer. So I am high enough in the chain to even close PRs at will.
Other engineers are encouraged to reach out to us staff engineers if they feel powerless on their own.
We can only do our best to not end up with a culture where people fear each other.
Document it as your groups operating principle and get the team to sign off on it. Point them to the doc.
This is the way. It’s how we got our CTO to stop sshing into pods to yolo his ideas.
Use automation checks. Most platforms allow adding tests for every small thing.
We have post commit hooks for agents as well as merge protection based on stuff like what you said
Here they just say “ohno so much effort, i already split it in 4, no use in split for the sake of splitting”
I mostly design and architect the systems, don’t write the code myself anymore.
I believe the important part is to keep working your critical thinking, don’t just blindly accept the output. Understand, scrutinize, consider, criticize.
Writing bad syntax and not remembering func signatures are obvious problems that will auto-resolve as you personally re-familiarize yourself with the tech you’re working with.
Malicious compliance, to some extent. The only people I can complain to are 3 levels down the AI train. Never let the AI update the git repo, review all changes it makes. I end up removing like 90% of any comments added as useless or too confusing to live; especially comments that have DO NOT REMOVE in them. Ends up taking about the same amount of time as if I just did the work myself. Quality is better, because the tool is good at what it does best.
I’m lucky enough to work somewhere that doesn’t dictate what tools I have to use. I don’t use it for code, because that’s just not fun for me. But I will use it once in a while when web search just totally fails me, but I know the answer is Out There (in the weights of scraped corpus).
I’m fighting back, I guess, mostly just by showing that it’s easy and enjoyable to do things without checking in with Sam Altman first. ;p
That’s the job now. If you need a job you’re going to have to get with the program. If not just quit!
In terms of maintaining skills, I have ~4 hours on a train each week that has shitty WiFi so I can’t use AI there - I spend some of that time doing manual coding on a side project.
I’m lead in my team and AI is being used to varying degrees. One colleague is a problem, but was a problem before AI as well. Me and my other three colleagues have a common understanding of you have to take ownership, understand what you’re doing, and document it.
As a reviewer, I ask for the information it lacks.
We (our company) has another project started with “AI first” too, and now still works mainly through “document features and behavior and stuff in md files and AI generates it” - so mostly about spec writing and AI generating. I don’t know how well that works, but I’ve heard bad more than good things (which may be common anyway) and it certainly hasn’t lead to meeting timelines (now more than half a year behind the original planned release).
Personally, I’m still skeptical about AI use, but do use it occasionally. Our project is simply too complex (and legacy and long history of changed dotnet technology as well). It’s more feasible on newer projects, but Blazor isn’t a straight forward framework either, mixing razor, html, css, component isolation, SAP lifecycle, render modes and whatnot.
I haven’t used AI to a degree where I feel it significantly [negatively] impacts my capabilities. Thankfully, my team hasn’t pivoted into that completely, either. I see the risk and hope pushes though. The promise of AI speeding things up. The customer saying “a bit more risk is fine”; but it’s on us to communicate the difference between risks (the bug fix missed one additional unknown place vs long term maintainability and its associated risks).
Which skill are you worried about atrophying? Writing code, reading code, or something else?
I find agents very useful for exploring, and understanding existing code bases I am not very familiar with, or if there are time constraints. One thing I have been thinking about, is using agents to assist with creating a plan, but instead of getting an agent to implement that plan, I’d rather make the code changes myself.
Another way could be regularly doing exercises at Exercism.
By being unemployed
Find an open-source project (better if it’s noAI), then work on it manually.
stop using AI?
Same situation as OP, when I do peer reviews using AI and it reports a list of flaws I just ignore it. If the Coderabbit doesn’t catch it then I’m just allowing the human error back into the code. It still sucks but there are future bugs to fix.
use AI to learn new stuff making sure to check stuff that smells fishy.
deleted by creator
In a similar boat. I’ve been programming since my family got a IBM 386 in the 90s and I started dabbling in the dark arts. I’ve been a career programmer for 20+ years now. I’ve loved it, all the way up until the past year or two.
Here are some of my rambling thoughts and perspectives, for whatever they are worth.
-
“Don’t try to fix someone else’s mistake while they are still in the process of making it.”. AI is both a useful tool and a giant shit show, but if your company wants the shit show, then let them have the shit show, do not carry their burden.
-
Lean into hobbies that aren’t on computers. I do woodwork, gardening, arts and crafts, sewing, home repairs, camping, etc. “Go touch grass” as it were.
-
“Fight fire with fire”. (I don’t understand that saying) But the point of it is to say, don’t manually review AI slop, if they are gonna slop 800 file PRs at you, AI slop review them and move on. The Titanic is sinking, you aren’t going to save it by frantically bailing with a bucket.
-
Programming is both an art form and a skill and it is also like riding a bike. You may not ride for years, but if you get on a bike it will come right back to you. Don’t stress or worry that your skillset is deteriorating, it will always be there. It may get rusty and need some lube, but it won’t go away.
-
When the AI bubble finishes popping, AI will still be around, but it may not be shoved into literally everything as much, and there will still be a place for talented people to do quality work. Examples from 2 of my top hobbies is that we have both automated farming and assembly line furniture factories, but handmade solid wood furniture is still around and worth doing, and there are still gardens in a lot of back yards.
-
Most of the people in the top positions in our governments and companies are completely and utterly unqualified to be there. You’ll be fine. Focus on being your best self, being happy with YOU. AI is here to stay, but talented people have not lost any value at all, know what you are worth, have some confidence, don’t let the slop get you down, there is literally slop in every aspect and career, try not to worry about it, ya know? Mass produced, low quality clothing and furniture exists, but people still sew and woodwork. It’s ok, be better than the baseline slop and you will have value to those who understand.
-
Being a “Jack of all Trades / Master of None” isn’t a bad thing, neither is the inverse a “Master of one thing and nothing else”. All of that is also very black and white thinking, it’s not reality. People are more than just their skills.
Final thoughts and summary: The AI slop is here to stay. As I learned in therapy “Don’t fight the current/flood/rising tide, learn to swim and float above it.”. The river is going to go where it is going to go, you can either be swept away and dragged under or you can sail along the surface and enjoy the breeze. I, personally, recommend the latter.
Good luck out there! You got this!
Fire with fire means doing a control burn wide enough that when the uncontrolled fire comes, there’s nothing for it to devour and keep expanding.
It works unless the wind speeds are too high and then embers can cross the burnt section and start a new fire. Some emebrs are known to fly 100s of meters and that’s a dangerous distance to maintain a control fire for
Ohhh that’s awesome! I knew about control burns, but hadn’t ever thought of that being the origin of the saying.
Yeah, I was complaining to a friend about how everything I like seems to be getting worse, and they basically said what you said: try to be zen about it, this is just a continuum of the same race to maximise profit that’s been going on before we were born. You just try your best to be a good person who cares about other people, and try not to sweat what you can’t control.
It is actually your fault for choosing to like all the wrong things, obviously. Choose things that are getting better next time. (Kidding)
But, seriously, yeah, just be zen about things, find your joy and try to find a few things that aren’t too dependent on others or stuff you can’t control. I do highly recommend some of the timeless crafts and hobbies, woods, fabrics, plants, art, etc.
And yeah, some things really are going to shit, but also, some things are getting better and it’s easy to focus on the bad and miss the good. But there is plenty to enjoy and be happy with.
Yup, be careful which wolves inside you that you feed.
Inside me there are three wol… Wait, where’s the third wolf?
Very wise words.
Thanks. This is a bit reassuring.
Fight forward with fire- My only gripe is if a prod issue arises, the ball will bubble up to my court and I hate to be caught with my trousers down
That is valid. So be the one to calmly point out that “800 file PRs are dangerous and will lead to bugs in production” and stand firm. You don’t have to refuse to review an 800 PR, but you can point out the position you are being put in.
Just because THEY chose to edit 800 files with an AI prompt doesn’t mean you have to be 100% on the hook for if/when it breaks. Drag that other person back into the spotlight with you and have them own it.
*Cartoon style shepherds cane hook their neck and pull them back on stage*
That’s so inspiring. Thanks!
Thank you for your words!
I have also been doing this since the 90s. All of this rings true.
I would say your whole thought process kind of floats above lemmy. Hopefully you won’t get a flood of douchevotes from zero-tolerance AI haters.
People are 100% valid in hating “AI” at present because currently it is causing a LOT of negatives and not many positives for the average person.
Think whatever you want about “AI” (machine learning/LLMs/chat bots) it is a tech that isn’t going away. Pandora’s box is wide open, no going back.
Wanting it to be used ethically and responsibly is good common sense.
I like the parallel of nuclear energy. We unlocked the secrets of the atoms and fission. We can either make nukes or we can make clean energy. People, rightfully, protested and “freaked out” because everything at the time was trending towards nukes, and look at that, they were right, however we did finally learn and now use fission as a power source and not for destruction. Yes the capability still exists to drop nukes, but we haven’t in a long time because of all the downsides.
I feel like LLMs and this wave of tech is going to be similar.
We will still have data centers, duh, but they won’t be in everyone’s damn back yard. We will still have LLMs, but we will train them responsibly and have guardrails and what constitutes fair use. We can have neat AI tools that assist us or speed up tedious tasks or automate boring things, that’s fine, but we can do that in healthy ways.
At least, that’s what we all hope for, so let’s help push for that to happen.
I agree with the sensible approach you’re talking about, but not with getting angry at every mention of AI as if it’s leprosy in Middle Ages Europe.
-



