cross-posted from: https://lemmy.zip/post/68752761 which was cross-posted from: https://sh.itjust.works/post/64103917
I thought about saying “you know it’s a grift when they collect personal information and leak it.” According to their Bible, you don’t need an app to pray. They say church (or a covenant, I forget, it’s been 30+ years since I read the KJV) is when any two people come together to talk about Jesus (sorry!). So, where does an app fit in? And why does that app need your personally identifiable information (referred to as PII in industry). Wouldn’t an all-knowing God already have it?
But you don’t have to know it’s a grift… I feel like this is proof the Vatican (or whoever made this app on their behalf, and thus speak on their behalf… and the Pope allegedly speaks on God’s behalf) themselves know it’s a grift. Because why would they need your PII?
I know, fools and their money are soon parted… just saw this on /all and figured the Fediverse’s top Atheism comm should have it.


If the sin he created us to commit is perfect, why does he punish us for it? You are ignoring the blatant contradictions. Cancer is perfect? He made that, too, right?
Please stop serving a literal death cult. Please stop defending rapists and pedophiles. Please stop glorifying violence.
Sin was introduced to humanity by the serpent when Adam and Eve ate the apple.
ill need sources for the claims you made in the last paragraph
…all of which god created, knowing this would happen.
You need look no further than the bible to confirm that all of christianity is a death cult, yahweh is a death god. Do you drink your savior’s blood and eat his flesh? Do you know how fucked-up that is?
Rapists and pedophiles: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6676731/
Murderers and genociders: https://www.worldhistory.org/Crusades/
All in the name of your god. Can you prove they are wrong and you are right? Everyone reasonable is still waiting for any proof of god’s existence before claiming they believe in it.
When cases of sexual abuse within the Catholic Church became known, the German Bishops’ Conference (Deutsche Bischofskonferenz, DBK) commissioned a study by an interdisciplinary consortium to determine the frequency of sexual abuse by Catholic clergy in Germany (the MHG study).
1670 persons belonging to the Catholic clergy who were accused of sexual abuse of minors were identified from their personnel files, corresponding to 4.4% of the clergy overall.
The DBK requested this study in the first place, and 4.4% of all clergy since the 1910s in Germany
Also, there have been many scientifically proven miracles.
They protect pedophiles until they cannot, if the evidence is overwhelming. How many are they still protecting today? How many were simply sent to other churches to harm more victims?
Still happening this year, actively covering up abuse: https://www.sltrib.com/religion/2026/01/27/catholic-abuse-powerful-utah/
Define “miracle”. Name one that has been scientifically proven.
an otherwise impossible act done by God
The Eucharistic Miracle of Buenos Aires
But you never proved or defined “god”.
Anyway, even catholic scientists admit your example is not a miracle: https://drjulesgomes.substack.com/p/catholic-scientists-debunk-assertions
Would you like to try another? Spoiler: they’re all bullshit, magic isn’t real. Please use your brain.
they APPEAR to be bleeding due to serratia marascens, a red pigmented bacterium.
But multiple tests for serratia are done in the case of eucharistic miracles
But without detailed reports? You just take them at their word?
You believe god is all-powerful, yes? And you believe this is how he chooses to interact with us?
https://catholic-miracles.com/miracle/eucharistic-tixtla-2006
this was identified as living human myocardium
Interesting, I’d love to see the report. Ah, it’s linked at the bottom of the article. Hmm, the link is unsafe, certificate expired two years ago. I proceeded with caution and saw… a 404 error.
There is no evidence of this supposed miracle.
https://catholic-miracles.com/miracle/eucharistic-sok-ka-2008
also, this one