This is partially me getting stuff off my chest. This post isn’t a response to, but was partially inspired by a dumpster fire of a thread from a couple days ago that appears to be deleted now.
I was lucky enough to be raised going to a Lutheran church that was “one of the good ones.” Going through confirmation was my first formalized exposure to thinking philosophically in a way public schools don’t teach. It was through the lens of the Bible, but the discussions we had were on finding our own interpretations and meanings on what’s right. It’s where I learned the phrase “sin boldly,” something I’ve internalized to this day as accepting that I can’t be perfect but to keep moving forward. At the end I had to give a faith statement and told my pastor to his face that I wasn’t certain I believed in this God guy but I liked a lot of the lessons, and he was fine with that.
I’m pretty agnostic at this point, though I wouldn’t call myself atheist, but my religious experience has pretty much always been a good one. The last time I went to church a few years ago they outright welcomed gay, trans, and other oppressed people and offered opportunities to do good in the community.
Whenever I see online atheists hating on religion, my instinct is to get defensive because my experience with it has been good. But since I became an adult it’s also become clear to me that a lot of religious people suck and use their religion as a shield and a cudgel to act hatefully. Piping up and saying “not all religious people” rings about the same as saying “not all men” though, so I usually just don’t say anything, especially in explicitly atheist spaces. But I felt a need to express my feelings, and this seemed an appropriate way to do so.
That is nice for you
Religion is still an invented ball and chain on the leg of humanity and it has to be rooted out if we want to survive this century.
Church saved my life. I would never in a million years attend some homophobic church that are antichoice, and I found one that fits the bill, full of the best friends I’ve ever had. Every Sunday is a joy.
Good for you.
Like diet, exercise routines, and OS choice, this should be kept to yourself.
Idk I think this is an appropriate post
It’s the people who use their definition of God to excuse the harm they want to do to others. I am really sorry that there is people here that won’t even grant you the decency of reading your post before they use their definition of God as an excuse to insult you. But I think there is comfort in knowing that these people are on a journey to a level of understanding that they will realise religion was supposed to fast track. That while there is no guy in the sky judging us, the power of a God is real. We haven’t been pulling this idea out of our asses for thousands of years we’ve been trying to quantify it with the means we can. Corporations are effectively the Gods because of atheist ignorance poisoning the concept of community. They realised religion was a scam and took notes so now religion is the “dumb” thing while corporations are key to life, and specifically for this forum, simultaneously denouncing corporations as the means of life. See I am doing it too sheesh
My unpopular opinion is that this is a fairly popular opinion. The vast majority of everyone worldwide is religious. Atheists are a pretty small minority, but loud on the internet.
Honestly, I’m glad you get something from it. Personally I’m burnt on it due to past negative experience. But I try not to allow my views negatively impact those who draw comfort from it (not those who are aggressive about it though). Everyone should be free to believe what they prefer provided it doesn’t cause harm to others.
It’s OK to take the good with the bad. Your experiences are your own. I was raised religious, and while I’d say it was a net negative for me, I do value some of it. I also feel the same way about religion in general: net negative probably, but with some real value.
Yeah I mean I went to a catholic school and even went two years to a benedictine college. Thing is its that lucky thing. that situational thing. no pedophilia in my time in school going on that I know of and as a westerner I have never had bombs exploded near me from opposing religious sects or other such violence. Priests have to get degrees so they are at least not uneducated so they have some basis for advice giving. often they have theology degrees but catholic institutions stress a lot of logic and philosophy along with that.
Jesuit formation will have you do a masters and maybe even a PhD
yeah PhD’s are common but I think at a min they require a bachelors. At least in the us. Im not sure how it works abroad.
it’s also become clear to me that a lot of religious people suck and use their religion as a shield and a cudgel to act hatefully.
Deep down, that’s really what the distrust in religion is all about. It’s not used for the valuable lessons it provides, it’s used as an in-group signifier to enable the very behavior those lessons oppose.
A connection to the greater universe is a sublime thing. The lessons inculcated are valuable to living a wholesome life, and there is great power to be had in community connection and fellowship. But it seems that for every person empowered by faith to be the best version of themselves, there are two who only use their “faith” to abuse those of other faiths.
I don’t think any serious person could suggest that religion has never made a positive impact on individual lives. The contention is the negative impact it has also enabled.
“I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ.” ~ Ghandi (allegedly, though snopes says it’s unknown).
Not everything religions teach is all bad. Not every religious group is all bad. All of the important teachings and community can be had without religion, though, and that would outweigh the bad that comes with the religious groups/teachings.
The church I attended most probably did harm in my life than good. I’ve said online before that I would have easily fallen into the far-right christian-nationalist facist fuckhead pipeline had social media been a thing; I was partyway their anyway until my probably my mid-20s. I was a good christian for the most part, but not a good person.
I’m also now an atheist. I’m glad that you found a group that helped, but how have they been to all the other people in their communities and the world? I tend to think organized religion definitely and even supernatural thinking generally do far more harm in the world than good.
Gandhi grew up near the Church of England, so I get where he’s coming from
To begin, this is not an attack on you. Most of your comment is fine, it just sparked many thoughts that I wrote down, so yes, some of it is unrelated to your comment. I am new to Lemmy.
I like most of what you say. However, people need to stop conflating religion with organized religion. I know that you specified organized but many are ignorant to the difference. This is something I see in every religious debate.
For example, it’s the same as somebody living in a country and getting compared to said countries government. On a national level, people have differing opinions of the government. Such as living in china, you wouldn’t point at an individual and say they were complicit in the genocide of the Uyghurs.
Similar to the hate Jews get today, or Christians, Muslims, etc. almost every single religion today is most commonly hated on the basis of what the governing bodies do. For atheists and non religious people to strengthen their arguments they need to learn how to separate the governing organization from the actual religion. Considering that the difference in atheism and other religions is simply how the world was created, further from that, the meaning and purpose of life in general.
Going on, I agree with your point on how religions don’t teach all bad. I think many forget that religion to the bones is a moral compass, and guide almost. Religion such as Christianity isn’t here to give you a bunch of rules and sentence you to hell if you don’t follow them. While many Christians do believe in a surface level interpretation of the Bible (which I heavily disavow), the Bible teaches how, why, and what life is. In the world we live in today most are equipped to decide and interpret life themselves, anything prior to the last 200 years however is a different story.
I think religion is a necessary human trait. Even if you aren’t “religious” being athiest is still, to me, a form of religion and ideology that helps people grapple with the idea and meaning of life.
I do not believe in a certain religion but do identify closer to Christianity.
Still, even today, religion is still necessary for many, and should be viewed from a stance that separates organizations and ignorant surface level interpretations.
I don’t understand your point in bringing up “far right Christian nationalist fascist fuckhead pipeline” seems like you hold a very hateful view on what you interpret as Christian nationalists. If you’re going to state things like that, then maybe actually flesh out a point on it instead of spewing it.
I’m a nationalist. Not a Christian nationalist, but a nationalist on a civic/economic point. Meaning that I don’t agree in a national religion but moreso a nation with a specific identity. This could be viewed as patriotism, considering yourself an American and having specific social norms - speaking English in commonplace, public manners, politeness, etc. economically, having national energy independence and self reliance.
However, I think the left in specific, has conflated what the average conservative believes. It’s easy to sit here and point a finger at “brainwashed magats” while ignoring how the same disease plagues both parties. Many “politically active” people are not actually political, hold no specific values, and often vote based on a few lukewarm policies. Ei not voting left because “communism” not voting right because “racist white people”.
By the way: Standing up for minorities and disadvantaged people also happens to be what Jesus taught.
I know there’s lots of people who call themselves Christians, who hate on homosexuals, women, trans folks etc. But the unfortunate reality is: They just got everything wrong. They believe pretty much in the polar opposite of what’s right according to their own literature.
Edit: And your link doesn’t work, it errors out, dunno if it got deleted.
If you try to be good while living in accordance to antic texts, you have to interpret and adapt those texts to your context.
Same if you are a cunt using those texts as an excuse.
Both are about interpretation just the same.
It’s hard, if not impossible, to write truly universal stories or rules.
The new testament isn’t exactly tolerant about everything.
Well… That’s kind of open to debate, isn’t it? Some people like to pick paragraphs which align with what they want to do and then assert this has to be followed literally. Some people say we need to interpret the stories.
I mean I know the earth isn’t 6000 years old, the universe wasn’t created by God in 6 days etc… We developed science since then and that gives us a fairly good answer to some of the big questions. But I have a hunch a lot of people read the Bible because they think there’s some “truth” embedded in there. Or some morals to follow.
When in reality, of course you shouldn’t follow any of the morals of the Bible. Because it’s filled with old stories which normalise selling your daughters and other heinous things. Or the sexist teachings of Paul in the newer parts. And of course lots of ommissions because the prophets of back then weren’t aware of how I live here in the modern city with all that technology, a fridge etc. So I can eat all the pork and shrimp I like and don’t have to follow the old rules.
But I think there’s some limitations. I mean once a text means anything and its opposite, it’s kinda worthless. And there isn’t much to interpret anymore.
But why shouldn’t there be truly universal stories or rules? I mean our origin story according to science is pretty much universal? That’s the point of science, to find objective answers. And I think we also have universal rules. For example the Golden Rule is a nice one to live by. It certainly is subject to nuance and doesn’t solve any situation… But it’s fairly good, a 5 yo can understand it and it’s difficult to abuse. And once I look at political/society stuff like the Human Rights declaration, which has almost universally been signed by all the sane representatives of societies… That’s also a fairly absolute guideline about what we should strive for.
“Not tolerant”!?!?! Religions use their bullshit texts to justify hate, murder, and genocide. Can you think of any genocides that are solely caused by religion? Right now. Anywhere in the world? Maybe the Middle-East?! Hmm?
The bible is a hate book. It spreads hate and division.
“But I don’t read that part!” Doesn’t matter, others do.
You’re conflating organized religion with what religions actually teach. It’s apparent you’ve never read or interpreted the Bible yourself. See my comment above.
Matthew 5:18 is, in conjunction with the Ten Commandments, a self-contained case study.
For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled.
You’re left with these options:
- Plain reading: You should blugeon adulterers and kids who talk back to their parents to death with rocks
- Interpret away “law”: sure, this religious guy talking about religion to people who shared his religion is talking about a law that’s totally just something in the neighborhood. Tortured reading that invites anything to mean anything — so the whole body of work is literally meaningless
- Interpret away that the passing of the earth and “all be fulfilled” are different: see above
- “This passage doesn’t count!” : then why should anyone believe any other? Makes the whole body of work vacuous
- “Well that’s not the TRUE Hebrew meaning” : see above, the whole thing becomes vacuous
- “Well Jesus said the whole first stone thing” : that’s worse than all the other points, means the whole thing is intentionally internally inconsistent, which… Makes the whole body of work vacuous. You can actually read it consistently, if you read the “first stone” bit as a command (“hey, you! Throw the rock!”) instead of a rhetorical device
Basically, it’s either a monstrous work, or vacuous for any or all of a variety of reasons, as a work of belief. It’s fine if it’s a meaningful as Zeus going about reaping future baby mommas as a goose, but that’s not how Yahwehian theists roll.
I would argue it’s a book used by hateful people to project themselves on to.
As the previous poster said, it’s left purposefully vague. A good lyric from an ACDC song was that religion is the blanket we throw over the mystery to give it shape.
And in that same way, we reflect ourselves back in it.
I think it did get deleted, I updated the post. Thanks for pointing that out.
There is no such thing as “one of the good ones”.
What did telling you about an unprovable judgemental god add to your education?
If you had received a similar education but without the concept of “sin” or damnation, would that education have been inferior?
I, too, was raised in religion but I cannot know how my life would be if I hadn’t been indoctrinated to think less of myself (sinful) and humanity (in need of salvation) in general, I doubt you can know, either.
“What did telling you about an unprovable judgemental god add to your education?“
It predisposed me to thinking deeply about the world that I would later flesh out studying philosophy in college. Asking “are the words in the Bible the literal words of God or inspired by them” planted a seed for epistemology and where knowledge comes from. Considering morals in biblical stories is just ethics. At an age when school mostly meant learning facts how to do specific things (which are good things to teach) in confirmation we were asked questions with less clear answers. We were told what our church proposed but were then immediately given the space to question that and come to our own conclusions. English class is the closest to that, but then the focus is also split on analyzing characters and writing well.
“If you had received a similar education but without the concept of “sin” or damnation, would that education have been inferior?”
I was raised in a church that taught damnation hasn’t really been a thing for a couple millennia so it’s not too relevant for my experience. If you take sin to mean “doing something bad” then I think any education that discusses ethics, the thinking of right and wrong, would be inferior without the concept of wrong.
It’s true that I can’t know how things would be different if I wasn’t raised religious, but so many things (like my parents’ own upbringing) would have to change for that different possibility that I just don’t think it’s worth thinking about very much. Like I said in my original post thinking on that Martin Luther quote “sin boldly” taught me to embrace my own shortcomings rather than beat myself up for them. I don’t think religion should make someone feel lesser, and I’m sorry that was your experience.
None of those things require religion. Philosophy can be studied without all the bullshit lies and trappings of religion. Adding in a bunch of make-believe doesn’t make morality or ethics or philosophy easier to study, it just obfuscates things. Being forced to question the nonsense that you’re being taught isn’t as valuable as just being taught things that aren’t nonsense in the first place. The only benefit you’ve stated to your religious upbringing is that it allowed you to become educated, but that education was poisoned with a whole bunch of irrelevant, harmful, and often downright false ideals and beliefs. The Bible has some good messages sure, but it’s not the only place to find those messages and they’re interspersed amongst a whole bunch of outdated, hateful, horrific messages as well.
Bravo, that is unpopular on lemmy.
Not exactly an opinion though, more a statement about an aspect of their life.
Yeah, this is a data point (an outlier for that matter), not an opinion.
It could be formulated as an opinion: “not every religious experience is terrible”. It would be a very weak opinion, because almost everything has outliers. I know for a fact that there are positive reports by Jews who were interned during WW2.
There’s a different comm called “justpost”. Just bringing that up since this was deleted before. Anyway…







