A reminder that as the US continues to threaten countries around the world, fedposting is to be very much avoided (even with qualifiers like “in Minecraft”) and comments containing it will be removed.

Image is of a Russian missile impacting Ukraine.


As we rapidly approach the fourth anniversary of the beginning of the Ukraine War (an anniversary I absolutely did not expect would occur while the two sides were still in combat), we have seen Russia turn to a new strategy, starting late last year but intensifying in December and now January.

Russia seems intent to disconnect Ukrainian cities from the electrical grid by focussing bombing on thermal, gas, and hydro stations, causing major power blackouts across the country. Russia is also bombing substations relatively close to Ukraine’s three nuclear power plants (Zaporzhye, the fourth, remains under Russia control), studiously avoiding hitting the premises of the NPPs themselves for obvious reasons. Even if they’re far away from the NPPs, striking the substations does have risks, because if the nuclear reactors aren’t shut off before the substations are bombed, there is a possibility that there will be insufficient backup power to prevent a meltdown - hence why Russia hasn’t really attempted to do this for four years.

Most of the electricity generated in Ukraine comes from the nuclear power plants, both because of the infrastructure they had initially (Ukraine was 7th in the world in nuclear electricity generation before the war) and because Russia has bombed most non-nuclear power stations and substations already. Over the last couple weeks, we have seen Ukrainian media fly into a frenzy about long-lasting blackouts, especially in the middle of winter. After the Zionist entity destroyed virtually all civilian infrastructure in Gaza while the West cheered on, they now appear to have changed their mind on whether such strikes are an effective and humanitarian option to subject millions of people to.

Regardless of whether you personally believe these Russian strikes are justified (I’m pretty iffy myself), it must be stressed that Ukraine has been bombing Russian tankers and oil refineries and power stations for a long time now, so in a sense, this is a retaliation. It’s also remarkable, compared to Western wars, that Ukraine was even still allowed to possess a functioning electrical grid for nearly four years into a war of this magnitude. That all being said, while Ukrainian strikes have been somewhat but not overly impactful on the Russian oil sector, the response is clearly very asymmetrical: Ukraine’s power grid is, according to Ukrainian energy corporations, now 70% degraded and is virtually impossible to now repair, and blackouts can last most of the day.

For everybody’s sake, I hope a ceasefire and peace deal will be reached soon. But after four years of seeing opportunities for an end to this war squandered over and over, I’m not holding my breath.


Last week’s thread is here.
The Imperialism Reading Group is here.

Please check out the RedAtlas!

The bulletins site is here. Currently not used.
The RSS feed is here. Also currently not used.

The Zionist Entity's Genocide of Palestine

If you have evidence of Zionist crimes and atrocities that you wish to preserve, there is a thread here in which to do so.

Sources on the fighting in Palestine against the temporary Zionist entity. In general, CW for footage of battles, explosions, dead people, and so on:

UNRWA reports on Israel’s destruction and siege of Gaza and the West Bank.

English-language Palestinian Marxist-Leninist twitter account. Alt here.
English-language twitter account that collates news.
Arab-language twitter account with videos and images of fighting.
English-language (with some Arab retweets) Twitter account based in Lebanon. - Telegram is @IbnRiad.
English-language Palestinian Twitter account which reports on news from the Resistance Axis. - Telegram is @EyesOnSouth.
English-language Twitter account in the same group as the previous two. - Telegram here.

Mirrors of Telegram channels that have been erased by Zionist censorship.

Russia-Ukraine Conflict

Examples of Ukrainian Nazis and fascists
Examples of racism/euro-centrism during the Russia-Ukraine conflict

Sources:

Defense Politics Asia’s youtube channel and their map. Their youtube channel has substantially diminished in quality but the map is still useful.
Moon of Alabama, which tends to have interesting analysis. Avoid the comment section.
Understanding War and the Saker: reactionary sources that have occasional insights on the war.
Alexander Mercouris, who does daily videos on the conflict. While he is a reactionary and surrounds himself with likeminded people, his daily update videos are relatively brainworm-free and good if you don’t want to follow Russian telegram channels to get news. He also co-hosts The Duran, which is more explicitly conservative, racist, sexist, transphobic, anti-communist, etc when guests are invited on, but is just about tolerable when it’s just the two of them if you want a little more analysis.
Simplicius, who publishes on Substack. Like others, his political analysis should be soundly ignored, but his knowledge of weaponry and military strategy is generally quite good.
On the ground: Patrick Lancaster, an independent and very good journalist reporting in the warzone on the separatists’ side.

Unedited videos of Russian/Ukrainian press conferences and speeches.

Pro-Russian Telegram Channels:

Again, CW for anti-LGBT and racist, sexist, etc speech, as well as combat footage.

https://t.me/aleksandr_skif ~ DPR’s former Defense Minister and Colonel in the DPR’s forces. Russian language.
https://t.me/Slavyangrad ~ A few different pro-Russian people gather frequent content for this channel (~100 posts per day), some socialist, but all socially reactionary. If you can only tolerate using one Russian telegram channel, I would recommend this one.
https://t.me/s/levigodman ~ Does daily update posts.
https://t.me/patricklancasternewstoday ~ Patrick Lancaster’s telegram channel.
https://t.me/gonzowarr ~ A big Russian commentator.
https://t.me/rybar ~ One of, if not the, biggest Russian telegram channels focussing on the war out there. Actually quite balanced, maybe even pessimistic about Russia. Produces interesting and useful maps.
https://t.me/epoddubny ~ Russian language.
https://t.me/boris_rozhin ~ Russian language.
https://t.me/mod_russia_en ~ Russian Ministry of Defense. Does daily, if rather bland updates on the number of Ukrainians killed, etc. The figures appear to be approximately accurate; if you want, reduce all numbers by 25% as a ‘propaganda tax’, if you don’t believe them. Does not cover everything, for obvious reasons, and virtually never details Russian losses.
https://t.me/UkraineHumanRightsAbuses ~ Pro-Russian, documents abuses that Ukraine commits.

Pro-Ukraine Telegram Channels:

Almost every Western media outlet.
https://discord.gg/projectowl ~ Pro-Ukrainian OSINT Discord.
https://t.me/ice_inii ~ Alleged Ukrainian account with a rather cynical take on the entire thing.


  • Tervell [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 months ago

    https://archive.ph/KUAEj

    Golden Dome is forcing the Pentagon to confront missile defense economics

    Gen. Michael Guetlein says deterrence hinges less on exquisite technology than on cost, production scale and industrial execution

    more

    Gen. Michael Guetlein, head of the Golden Dome missile defense program, said the success of this effort depends on the ability to field defenses that are both scalable and affordable, including new directed-energy and other non-kinetic technologies aimed at lowering the cost of intercepting missiles. Speaking Jan. 23 at the AFCEA Space Industry Days conference in Los Angeles, Guetlein said the program’s central challenge is the economics of missile defense, specifically how the cost of each intercept limits how many interceptor shots the United States can afford to keep on hand. He described this as an issue of “magazine depth,” a term that refers to the number of interceptors available to respond to an attack. Missile defense systems with limited magazines can be exhausted quickly if an adversary launches multiple weapons or employs decoys. The thinking is that a system that can only handle a small number of intercepts does not provide credible deterrence. The “cost per kill” has to come down, said Guetlein. Current U.S. missile defense interceptors, which were designed for regional or limited homeland defense missions, cost millions of dollars apiece and are used to defeat much lower-cost weapons. Analysts have pointed out that this imbalance invites adversaries to overwhelm defenses through volume.

    “We have the most exquisite capabilities on the planet, with a high probability of kill. They do not miss but they take forever to build. They’re exceptionally expensive, and as a result, I have very small magazine depths, because the cost per kill is so high,” said Guetlein. “I have to flip that equation.” Golden Dome is the Defense Department’s effort to design a next-generation homeland missile defense architecture capable of countering advanced threats such as hypersonic glide vehicles, modern ballistic missiles and fractional orbital bombardment systems. Unlike existing missile defense programs that rely largely on ground- and sea-based interceptors, Golden Dome envisions a multi-layered system that integrates space-based sensors, communications and interceptors into a unified framework.

    Pressure to scale production

    Guetlein told the AFCEA conference that what the Pentagon needs immediately from industry is the ability to scale production and deliver lower-cost ways to defeat missiles, including non-kinetic options. Analysts say space-based interceptors capable of maneuvering on orbit could be effective but would also be among the most expensive elements of any future architecture. Directed energy systems, including lasers and neutral particle beams, are among the concepts Guetlein has highlighted as potential ways to drive down the cost per shot while increasing magazine depth. Neutral particle beams, which remain largely experimental, would theoretically operate at near-light speed and damage targets by disrupting electronics or generating heat. Guetlein also pointed to “left of launch” defenses, a phrase used to describe efforts to stop missile threats before a launch occurs. That can include intelligence and surveillance activities that detect preparations, as well as non-kinetic actions that complicate or delay an adversary’s ability to fire. The goal here is to reduce the number of missiles that ever need to be intercepted. “Because when you’re trying to defend something the size of the United States, I can’t do it the way we’ve done it overseas. I have to have a new way of doing it,” he said.

    The urgency to scale production and lower costs has already shaped Pentagon investment decisions. The Defense Department recently announced plans to directly invest in the production of interceptor missiles built by Lockheed Martin and solid rocket motors produced by L3Harris Technologies. While not labeled as Golden Dome funding, those investments align directly with the program’s emphasis on deeper magazines and lower per-unit costs. They also speak to Guetlein’s broader argument that Golden Dome is less a technology challenge than an industrial one. “We’re accelerating private capital investment, and we’re taking private equities’ view of the defense industrial base,” Guetlein said, adding that he regularly meets with investment bankers to help stabilize demand signals as companies seek capital to expand capacity. That emphasis on economics was echoed in the National Defense Strategy released Jan. 23, which identifies defense of the homeland as the Pentagon’s top priority. “The Department will prioritize efforts to develop President Trump’s Golden Dome for America, with a specific focus on options to cost-effectively defeat large missile barrages and other advanced aerial attacks,” the document states.

    Architecture to remain secret

    Guetlein said details of the Golden Dome architecture will remain classified. He said conversations with industry are occurring almost exclusively through one-on-one engagements, rather than open forums. After his confirmation as Golden Dome program manager in July, Guetlein said foreign actors began cyber targeting the defense industrial base, prompting senior officials to clamp down on public discussion. “We have been quiet,” he said. “I have not been talking to industry consortiums. I’ve not been talking to the press. I’ve not been talking to the think tanks, and it wasn’t until September I was allowed to even start talking to the Hill.” That secrecy has begun to draw scrutiny. In a defense spending bill for fiscal year 2026 approved by the House last week, appropriators said they support Golden Dome but faulted the administration for failing to provide sufficient detail on how $23 billion in mandatory funding has been allocated. The bill directs the Pentagon to submit more detailed plans and justifications. Guetlein said the program is on track to meet the administration’s timeline.

    “By the summer of ‘28 we will be able to defend the entire nation against ballistic missiles as well as other generation aerial threats,” he said, calling Golden Dome an “unprecedented challenge.”

    uh, yeah, sure… lenin-sure

    As program director, Guetlein reports to the deputy secretary of defense and has been granted unusually broad authorities. “I have budget authority, contract authority, hiring authority, technical authority, security authority to get after protecting the homeland.” The Golden Dome office, Guetlein said, currently has 52 staff and expects to grow to about 100, even though he is authorized to reach 300. Requirements are set centrally, but procurement is decentralized across the services and agencies. “I’ve got the Space Force buying SBIs. I’ve got the Army buying munitions and sensors. I’ve got the Navy buying munitions. I’ve got the Missile Defense Agency buying next generation interceptors, glide phase interceptors, and a whole host of other capability,” Guetlein said. He also works closely with the Space Development Agency’s low Earth orbit sensor and transport network. Guetlein noted that the Missile Defense Agency’s SHIELD procurement vehicle is not part of Golden Dome, despite recent headlines about the large number of vendors selected to compete under the contract. SHIELD, he said, is simply “a tool that I can reach in and use if I need to.”

    Command-and-control layer

    One of the most demanding pieces of the program, he said, is the command-and-control layer that connects sensors, decision-makers and interceptors across services and classification levels. That software “glue layer” must be demonstrated this summer, integrated with interceptors in 2027, and shown operating against credible threats in 2028. To speed that effort, the Golden Dome office formed a command-and-control consortium of six companies working side by side, an arrangement Guetlein described as a departure from traditional contracting approaches. Beyond technology, Guetlein said entrenched culture and organizational behavior pose daily obstacles. He criticized what he described as a compliance-driven mindset that prioritizes risk elimination over speed and integration. “We cannot keep doing business as usual,” he said. “That’s really what our challenge is going to be.” While President Trump has floated the idea of international involvement in Golden Dome, Guetlein said he has not yet been authorized to engage allies. “Everything we are doing is allied by design,” he said, adding that planning already assumes future integration of partner capabilities and access to overseas territory for sensors. Golden Dome has figured into a broader geopolitical dispute over Greenland, where Trump has said expanded U.S. access would be “vital” to the program, including for radar and interceptor deployment.

  • xiaohongshu [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    edit-2
    10 months ago

    Answering some questions from last week’s discussion that I was unable to get to:

    @QinShiHuangsShlong@hexbear.net

    The imperial examination system was not an abstract cultural mechanism. It was a superstructure rooted in a landlord economy based on agrarian surplus extraction. That economic base was fundamentally destroyed in the twentieth century. Land reform eliminated the landlord class. Collectivization dismantled hereditary property relations. Socialist industrialization replaced agrarian production as the dominant foundation of society.

    What remains today is not the continuation of that system, but a modern bureaucratic structure necessary to govern an industrialized society of 1.4 billion people. Bureaucracy is not uniquely Chinese. The Soviet Union developed similar contradictions without Confucianism, dynasties, or imperial examinations. To explain modern governance primarily through ancient lineage systems is not materialist it is a prime example of cultural determinism.

    Chairman Mao understood Chinese history deeply, yes. But he did not conclude that socialism was threatened by “thousands of years of tradition.” He concluded that new bourgeois elements emerge within socialist society itself.

    The danger lay not in ancient habits, but in the material conditions of socialist transition: unequal authority, division of labor, persistence of commodity relations, and the separation of cadres from the masses. That is why Mao spoke of “capitalist roaders,” not “imperial bureaucrats.” His analysis was forward-looking, not civilizationally fatalistic. If the problem were simply inherited culture, socialism would be impossible by definition.

    Following your reasoning, Mao must be an extremist who simply wanted to cause maximum chaos and destruction, which is essentially the narrative pushed by Western propaganda.

    Because why would Mao want to completely break with thousands of years of tradition with the Cultural Revolution? Perhaps he had identified crucial elements within the Chinese societal traditions that are responsible for propagating such reactionary features in the contemporary socialist movement? Otherwise the entire logic behind Cultural Revolution would not make sense if it is just to correct for some mistake about capitalist restoration.

    He was labeled as an extremist and a radical, yes, but he was probably not completely wrong. Look at what happened after the collapse of the USSR - 70 years of institutions simply went down the drain, and the society reverted to its past, reactionary form, just like that. It demonstrates that 70 years of institutions by themselves had failed to transform human behavior. Mao probably was on to something about culture and tradition.

    (Note: personally, I am not onboard with the Cultural Revolution like the ultra-left does, but I am starting to see the point)

    Understanding this, you will realize that the prioritization of East Asian culture on education did not just appear out of nowhere. It has clear ties with class mobility that goes back thousands of years. I guarantee you it’s not because people in East Asia like to study and read books lol. It has more to do with how you (and your entire family) can leap into a higher class and leave behind generations of poverty, a tradition that is still very much alive in modern day China.

    Dialectical materialism does not promise purity. It explains motion. And motion means struggle, correction, instability, and transformation.

    Yet none of these are present in your arguments. They are mere rhetoric that did not tell us anything about the Chinese system. Your arguments essential boil down to: “China is building towards socialism, there are problems and they are being corrected”. Anyone can make those statements, but there is no explanatory and predictive power. It is not dialectics, it is at best, sophistry.

    Let’s go over how dialectics work, using Marx’s classic example (in a very simplified form for illustration purpose):

    1. Maximization of capital accumulation necessarily involves the abolishment of the feudal serfdoms to unleash the productive force of labor
    2. The transformation of agrarian serfs into industrial workers emancipates the peasantry from being tied to their land, thereby unleashing the revolutionary potential of the newly formed proletariat class whose labor is no longer tied to land.

    Marx identified a key contradiction in the industrialization process undertaken by the capitalist class.

    To maximize capital accumulation, they had to destroy the feudal system that held back the productive capacity, yet in the process, it emancipates the peasantry from their land and tied their labor to production, not land as it did previously. To maximize profit, the industrialists needed to extract surplus value from labor; yet the process also caused the labor who is no longer attached to their land to have “nothing to lose but their chains”. Therefore, capitalism creates the necessary conditions for its own demise and paves the way towards socialism.

    Note how the dialectical process captures the causal interactions between labor and capital under the process of capitalist industrialization. It has explanatory power. It has predictive value. It actually tells us something about the capital accumulation process that goes beyond mere rhetoric. It may not be entirely accurate, but it is a scientific form of socialism that goes far beyond what the utopians had attempted in their own analysis.

    ——

    @thethirdgracchi@hexbear.net

    This part is always so interesting to me, because on the face of it the imperial examination system is deeply egalitarian in a way no other ancient civilisation approached. The idea that it was not genes but effort and intelligence that would allow you access to a better life is astounding to see so far back. There’s always been a tension between trying to co-opt that examination system for the already existing great families, but its existence at all is always so shocking to me.

    As I had explained in the class mobility post, the Imperial Court Examination was a response to the feudal oligarchy, most famously the Guanlong group that had begun to erode the authority of the emperors by the 5th-8th century.

    It was essentially a parallel track to promote court officials loyal to the emperors, acting as a counterbalance force against the feudal oligarchy in the imperial court.

    By the time we get to Northern Song in the 10th-11th century, the feudal oligarchy in the form of menfa (门阀) had been completely purged (Huang Chao rebellion put the final nail in the coffin) and the Song emperors had assumed total control of the bureaucracy. Ironically, this caused the weakening of the state control over its peripheral vassals and eventually led to the invasion by the Jurchens (Jin) and the Mongols (Yuan).

    See my recommendation below for Prof. Zhou Xueguang’s book that elaborates on the cyclical centralized and decentralized nature of the Chinese state political apparatuses.

    ——

    @truly@lemmygrad.ml

    Please can you correct my understanding: Modern day China has a bureaucratic class, Mao has noted the tendency toward a new bureaucratic class, Ancient China had a bureaucratic class, we have not seen the system sustain itself without a cultural revolution.

    While, yes, the bureaucratic tendency is real, are we not witnessing the system attempt to renew itself? We are having a discussion over an unsubstantiated article, all we know for sure is that they were removed as part of corruption investigations. We must simply wait and see.

    I am as skeptical of the article as you are (whether it is about the nuclear secrets). However, the purge of the highest ranks in the CMC (and especially Zhang Youxia, who is noted for his close ties with Xi) is real and exposes a corruption problem within the military that has permeated even at the very top. We simply don’t know the details (and probably won’t get the true details, like ever) and the longer term consequences. But for sure, this isn’t some mid ranking officials who took money on the side.

    For understanding the evolution of Chinese bureaucracy, the logic behind the cyclical centralization and decentralization of power, I strongly recommend Prof. Zhou Xueguang’s The Institutional Logic of Governance in China: An Organizational Approach, who is professor of sociology at Stanford.

    It is a very well researched and foundational academic text towards understanding how the enormous bureaucratic system operates at various levels. I know of plenty PhD students specializing in Chinese history and sociology who swear by it.

    • QinShiHuangsShlong [none/use name]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      edit-2
      10 months ago

      You are seemingly misunderstanding my argument, leading you to arguing against a position I did not make.

      At no point did I ever infer or imply Chairman Mao was an extremist, irrational, or motivated by chaos. That framing is your insertion, not a logical consequence of what I said. Recognizing the limits and contradictions of the Cultural Revolution is not equivalent to repeating Western liberal narratives. Marxism does not require us to sanctify every tactic in order to defend the revolutionary line behind it.

      Chairman Mao was obviously correct that class struggle continues under socialism. He was again obviously correct that bourgeois elements can emerge within the Party itself. He was yet again correct that institutions alone do not guarantee socialist consciousness. I disputed none of this.

      Your reasoning begins to depart from dialectical materialism through what you identify as the material source of those contradictions.

      You are treating “culture,” “tradition,” and long civilizational memory as semi-independent causal forces, capable of reproducing class society even after the economic base has been transformed. That is the upmost of idealism.

      Marxism does not deny that ideology exists. It insists that ideology is shaped and reproduced by material relations. If culture itself were decisive, then land reform, collectivization, and socialist industrialization should have failed immediately. Instead, they succeeded in abolishing entire classes that had ruled China for millennia. That alone falsifies the idea that tradition possesses autonomous historical power.

      What Chairman Mao identified was not tradition acting on socialism, but material contradictions produced inside society:

      1. the persistence of commodity production
      2. unequal authority within the division of labor
      3. administrative privilege
      4. uneven development between town and countryside
      5. separation between leadership and masses

      These are not cultural remnants. They are structural contradictions of transition. This distinction is important.

      If reaction emerges because “Chinese tradition reproduces hierarchy,” then socialism is impossible not only in China, but anywhere with history. Marxism collapses into civilizational pessimism.

      Chairman Mao never argued that. He argued that new bourgeois relations emerge from socialist production itself, not from the Tang dynasty.

      On the USSR: its collapse does not demonstrate the supremacy of tradition over institutions. It demonstrates the failure to maintain proletarian political power over the state and economy. The material base had already shifted long before 1991, market mechanisms, managerial autonomy, labor commodification, and elite reproduction were already dominant.

      What collapsed in 1991 was not socialism’s cultural shell reverting to tsarism. It was a system whose class character had already changed. There was no feudal restoration in Russia. There was capitalist restoration. Another important distinction.

      Regarding education and class mobility: yes, examination-based advancement historically functioned as a route out of poverty. But again, you are mistaking continuity of form for continuity of essence. Modern educational competition exists because:

      1. industrial economies require credentialed labor
      2. developmental states allocate opportunity through standardized selection
      3. surplus labor competes for limited upward mobility channels

      This is true in China, South Korea, Singapore, and also in France, Japan, and Germany. The Gaokao is not the imperial exam reborn. It is a modern mechanism of labor allocation under industrial conditions.

      Forms may resemble each other. Their class content does not. This is precisely why Marx warned against superficial historical analogy.

      Now to dialectics. You are absolutely correct that dialectical analysis must have explanatory and predictive power. But dialectics does not mean identifying one contradiction and projecting it linearly forward forever.

      Dialectics analyzes motion through contradiction under specific material conditions. Your capitalism example works because Marx identified:

      1. capital accumulation as the dominant motion
      2. proletarianization as its necessary condition
      3. surplus extraction as its internal contradiction

      Now apply the same rigor to socialist transition.What is the dominant motion today? It is not tradition reproducing itself. It is the contradiction between:

      1. socialist political power
      2. and partial commodity-based economic mechanisms
      3. under conditions of uneven development and imperialist pressure

      From that contradiction arise:

      1. wealth polarization
      2. bureaucratic stratification
      3. corruption
      4. ideological tension

      These phenomena are not residues of feudalism. They are contradictions produced by development itself. This is why Chairman Mao emphasized continuing revolution , not because ancient culture would resurrect itself, but because new bourgeois relations continuously emerge unless actively constrained.

      That struggle cannot be permanent chaos. It must be institutionalized, regulated, corrected, and rebalanced, precisely what was missing in the late Cultural Revolution period.

      To say this is not to reject Chairman Mao and Mao Zedong Thought. It is to apply Mao Zedong Thought materially, not dogmatically.

      Finally, your accusation that my position reduces to “there are problems and they are being corrected” misses the point entirely. The explanatory power lies here:

      1. China’s contradictions arise from accelerated socialist development using limited market mechanisms
      2. those mechanisms generate bourgeois tendencies
      3. the Party retains political dominance over capital
      4. struggle therefore occurs primarily within the socialist state itself, not between external classes

      That predicts instability, anti-corruption cycles, policy reversals, re-centralization, and ideological tightening, exactly what we observe.

      That is dialectics. Not cultural fatalism. Not civilizational inheritance. Not pessimism disguised as depth. Contradictions are real. They are sharp. They are dangerous. But they are not proof that history is repeating itself, only that socialism, is a long and uneven process of transformation, not a clean rupture where motion ceases.

      • xiaohongshu [none/use name]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        edit-2
        10 months ago

        I think we are talking past each other. You seem to think that I am insisting the entire feudal institutions are inherited without changes, while I have clearly said that these evolved out of the traditional institutions and repurposed under capitalist mode of production.

        I will give you an example: patriarchy is a feudal institution, yet it continues to perpetuate in modern day society to serve a different purpose under capitalism. This does not negate the fact that patriarchy emerges out of its feudal past and retains (“inherits”) many elements, reactionary and destructive, that hold back socioeconomic progress.

        This is the essence of Mao’s Cultural Revolution. Mao saw the need for a complete and decisive break with the past traditions and saw it as a necessity towards building socialism. Of course, the liberal reformers disagree, we all know that. I am not saying Mao is completely right here but you are ignoring an important aspect of how modern Chinese bureaucracy is shaped by dismissing them all out of hand. Traditions don’t simply disappear, they evolve and stay latent in how we interact with the world every day.

        China is the only civilization in the world today that has retained a continuity of its institutions for over 2200 years. To ignore that role and impact of such long-lasting traditions and equate them with the much younger, modern Western states is to ignore the historical role of such institutions in the sociopolitical and economic spheres of modern day China.

        Similarly, gaokao is not the exact same institution as the Imperial Court Examination, but it is an extension and an evolution of such system. The tradition of “lineage” that has been so dominant throughout Chinese history is very much alive in modern day China’s academia, private sector and government bureaucracy.

        I don’t know if you are Chinese or not, but anyone who grows up in the culture knows just how such “unwritten rules” remain in modern Chinese society, whether you are interacting with family members and at the workplace with your superiors etc.

        • xiaohongshu [none/use name]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          10 months ago

          Also, I don’t mean to accuse: I am getting ChatGPT vibes here. Are these posts assisted with LLM in some ways?

          I am trying to compose a detailed response to your long comment and it took more than an hour just to write the outlines, whereas yours took mere minutes to respond. The more I read, the less these arguments make sense to me.

          There are a lot of circular ChatGPT-like arguments (“it’s not this, it’s that”) so I don’t even know how to respond without concrete examples being presented. I feel like I am arguing with an LLM lol (no offense, but maybe you do write like that).

          If you’re interested in furthering the discussion, we need concrete examples beyond the vague LLM-style sophistry where we can go in depth and dissect in detail the historical progression of the Chinese bureaucratic system. Otherwise the answers are always going to be vague and we go in circles.

        • QinShiHuangsShlong [none/use name]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          10 months ago

          I think I understand your point more clearly now, and you’re right that institutions do not vanish magically when one mode of production replaces another. I like all marxists fully accepts that superstructural forms can persist, mutate, and be repurposed under new material conditions. Patriarchy is indeed the classic example to explain this.

          But this is exactly where precision matters. Patriarchy persists under capitalism not because of cultural memory alone, but because it continues to serve material functions: reproduction of labor power, unpaid domestic labor, inheritance control, and stabilization of wage relations. Its survival is not explained by history, but by utility to the dominant mode of production. Without that utility, patriarchy would decay rapidly regardless of tradition. The same standard must be applied to bureaucracy, lineage, and examination systems.

          If a social form persists, scientific socialism through dialectical materialism demands we ask: what material role does it currently play? Not where it came from, but why it continues to reproduce itself today. This is where I think your argument still slips from materialism toward historical determinism. You are correct that China has unusual institutional continuity. That fact alone, however, does not explain causality. Continuity describes form; it does not explain motion.

          What reproduces hierarchy today is not the memory of imperial lineage, but concrete mechanisms:

          1. cadre evaluation systems
          2. administrative ranking structures
          3. control over resource allocation
          4. credential monopolies
          5. urban–rural stratification
          6. uneven regional development

          These mechanisms would generate elite reproduction even if the imperial examinations had never existed. This is precisely why similar phenomena appear in the USSR, Vietnam, South Korea, Singapore, and even France’s grandes écoles system, societies with no shared civilizational origin.

          The resemblance is structural, not genealogical. On gaokao: yes, there is historical resonance. But resonance is not determination. The gaokao functions today as a labor-allocation mechanism under industrial conditions. Its brutality comes from scarcity and competition, not Confucian morality. If economic structure changed such that upward mobility was not concentrated into narrow credential channels, the social meaning of education would change accordingly, just as it already has for segments of the urban middle class.

          That demonstrates material causation, not cultural destiny. Regarding “unwritten rules,” when have I denied their existence. But unwritten rules are not ancient ghosts; they are informal adaptations to power concentration. Wherever access to resources depends on approval from superiors, informal relations emerge, whether in Chinese ministries, Soviet factories, Wall Street firms, or Western universities.

          Calling this “lineage culture” risks obscuring the real issue: bureaucratic power without sufficient mass supervision. Chairman Mao understood this clearly. The Cultural Revolution was not an attempt to annihilate tradition for its own sake. It was an attempt (however flawed in execution) to prevent the crystallization of a new bureaucratic class by mobilizing the masses against administrative privilege. Its target was not history. Its biggest target was power.

          That is why Chairman Mao emphasized “those in authority taking the capitalist road,” not scholars, families, or customs as such. He did not argue that culture autonomously reproduces class society. He argued that class society reproduces culture. This is a fundamental difference. If tradition itself were the decisive force, then socialist transformation would depend primarily on ideological purification. Chairman Mao rejected that. He insisted that ideological struggle must be rooted in mass participation and material change, not moral critique.

          This is also why later socialist practice emphasized institutionalization rather than permanent mobilization, not because the problem disappeared, but because contradiction must be handled at a level consistent with development.

          So yes forms evolve. Yes history leaves traces. Yes people experience continuity in daily life. But dialectical materialism draws a firm line:

          1. History conditions forms.
          2. Material relations determine motion.
          3. When explanation begins to rely on civilizational uniqueness rather than present material function, analysis loses predictive power and turns inward.

          The question is not and should not be whether tradition exists. The question is what reproduces power today. That is where scientific socialists must always place their focus, not in inherited memory, but in living relations of production and authority that can actually be transformed.

          • xiaohongshu [none/use name]@hexbear.net
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            10 months ago

            Sorry I really don’t want to accuse you of anything, but the way you write is all ChatGPT-style sophistry.

            “It’s not this, but that…” “This is precisely where it matters.”

            Lots and lots of these circular statements. There is no concrete example or evidence being presented here. It’s all vague statements you typically get from chatting with an LLM. I spent the last hour trying to write a detailed response but I don’t even know how to respond when the statements are sufficiently vague that you can write any answers and they still fit and continue to go in circles.

            • QinShiHuangsShlong [none/use name]@hexbear.net
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              10 months ago

              We keep going in circles because you remain entrenched in an idealist framework, even while sometimes using materialist language. You constantly redirect the analysis back to historical origin, tradition, or civilizational continuity. When asked to identify concrete present-day mechanisms, the answer becomes imperial examinations, lineage culture, or institutional inheritance, rather than existing relations of production and authority.

              When I distinguished between historical origin and present function, you treat that as if I am denying history itself, which allows the same claim to be restated without actually engaging the critique.

              You have repeated this consistently. When comparative cases are raised (the USSR, France, Japan, Korea) instead of explaining what is materially different in China, you bypass comparison by asserting uniqueness. When patriarchy is discussed, you accept that it persists because it still performs material labor functions, but you refuse to apply that same standard to bureaucracy or lineage, never specifying what concrete economic function those traditions perform today. When the USSR collapse was raised, material transformation was replaced with cultural reversion.

              This is why the discussion cannot move forward. You continusly treat history as an active causal force in itself, rather than something whose continued influence must be explained through present material conditions. Your analysis is idealist: tradition is allowed explanatory power independent of political economy. As long as that framing remains, we will keep talking past each other.

              As for my writing style, it may come across as rigid or formulaic simply because this is not my native language, I am still far from 100% comfortable in it and thus fallback on standard easy to use structures to try best convey my thoughts.

  • jack [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    10 months ago

    So last Friday we saw a general strike in Minneapolis - the first such action in the US in 80 years. This Friday? PSL has assessed there is the opportunity for a nationwide one-day general strike. Branches across the country are going to be mobilized based on the lessons from last week to immediately massify this call. Shit’s going down.

  • MLRL_Commie [comrade/them, he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    10 months ago

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/jan/28/can-venezuelas-delcy-rodriguez-become-a-latin-american-deng-xiaoping

    Article filled with brainworms, but I am wondering what Hexbears think about this concept in general. Delcy trying to follow the model of Deng (hallowed be his name deng-cowboy) seems like a very difficult path without major change to the method. Deng was able to leverage Chinese huge proletarian labor capacity, many ports, and sovereignty to invite capital, make that capital reproduction valuable for the capitalists, and benefit from the effect of built infrastructure and knowledge. Venezuela would need to make some huge changes to their infrastructure very quickly to be able to do this (could be posisble if enough outside investment comes) and would be taking a bigger risk seeing as the bolviarian revolution less defensible is than the CCP was. That, or Venezuela tries to do a Opening Up but limiting it to the oil industry… which I think is a bad strategic path and will result in failure (with Oil being phased out for cheaper renewables). And it will only result in useless built up knowledge and infrastructure.

    What am I missing here? Are there other strategic options that I’m ignoring or don’t know about?

    Or is this bullshit that is being assumed about Venezuela but not actually how anything on the ground is working?

    • QinShiHuangsShlong [none/use name]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      edit-2
      10 months ago

      Materially, she cannot. Deng’s strategy was embedded in a specific conjuncture of Chinese state power, proletarian capacities, and controlled capital integration. Venezuela’s productive forces have been decimated, class structures distorted by imperialist pressures actively reshaping political power. Without socialist reconstruction of productive forces and class relations, what is being called “reform” would really be a repositioning within global capitalism. If she was to walk a Deng style path currently it would be far more apt to call her Venezuela’s Gorbachev or Yeltsin.